Deutsche Bank and the Big Short

The movie ‘The Big Short’ reminds us how the toxicity of Deutsche Bank’s historic activity and culture continue to infect the bank and broader financial system today. Deutsche is the most leveraged big bank in the world, with assets 37 times core equity tier one capital. Half of these assets – $762 billion – are over-the-counter derivatives, the legacy of its growth before the crisis.

Continue reading..

Unravelling LOBOs

A few weeks ago, I was with Channel 4 Dispatches reporter Antony Barnett speaking to Sheffield Labour MP Clive Betts. We were on a park bench in some gardens next to the Houses of Parliament and we briefed Betts about our findings on Lender Option Borrower Option (LOBO) loans to UK councils – findings that were seen by a Channel 4 audience of over 1 million last Monday.

Continue reading..

House of Debt

The authors are experts at crunching microeconomic data on American borrowing patterns and uncovering explanations for what they see. Their starting point is the remarkable statistic for US household debt, which doubled to $14 trillion between 2000 and 2007. This build up of debt was responsible for the ensuing havoc because of its effect on borrowers, Mian and Sufi argue.

To understand this argument, consider mortgage borrowers versus those who invest in their mortgages via bank deposits. The borrowers tend to be poorer than the investors, who have spare cash. As Mian and Sufi put it, a poor man’s loan is a rich man’s asset.

However, the risk distribution is highly asymmetric because mortgage holders have a senior claim on property while the borrowers’ equity claim is junior, and gets wiped out first. When US house prices fell from late 2006 onwards, losses were concentrated among the poorest segment of the population who had levered exposure, while the richest segment ““ the savers ““ were cushioned.

That explains why inequality increased during the Great Recession, but Mian and Sufi don’t stop there. Using economic analysis that reads like a detective story, they show how the evaporation of poor peoples’ wealth led to a collapse in spending, effectively causing the Great Recession itself. To show causality, they point out that spending initially fell the most in areas of biggest housing wealth declines.

Continue reading..

Shredded: Inside RBS, the Bank that Broke Britain

Ian Fraser Birlinn 2014 A bank whose bailout costs £45 billion deserves to have more than one book written about it. In September 2013 we had Iain Martin's Making It Happen (see my review here), and now fellow Scottish journalist Ian Fraser has published Shredded. Fraser's 500-page book piles on the detail as we meet a cast…

Continue reading..

Volcker Sunlight Should be the Best Disinfectant

On the fourth anniversary of the Dodd-Frank Act, the big US banks are still black boxes in terms of their trading activity. However regulators are now getting a bit more information. Over the last month, the big banks have started providing them with so-called reporting metrics under the Volcker Rule, so that the rule’s curbs on proprietary trading can be enforced.

Continue reading..